Peter 'Happy' Thomas (happypete) wrote,
Peter 'Happy' Thomas
happypete

It's printed in black and white

Read this, for some interesting commentary on the great "finding vs. looting debate."

http://blogcritics.org/archives/2005/09/01/191113.php

[EDIT: additional information, including the source of the "looting" photo; yes, the photographer witnessed and described actual...wait for it...LOOTING!]

http://www.salon.com/news/feature/2005/09/01/photo_controversy/

I think we can put to bed whether or not the two light-skinned people in the Agence France picture were looting or, as he put it, "finding." The first-person account of the photographer pretty much says it all.

I agree, though, that the other picture--nearly identical--that accuses the dark-skinned man in the picture of looting could easily have been the same situation. What I don't have, in this case, is the context from the photographer or other witnesses. Just as one photographer reported exactly what he witnessed, in context, this other might have--or he might have leapt to an unfounded conclusion.

I'm doing something unusual for me and disabling comments--if you really want to discuss this issue with me from either side, I'll be glad to do so in e-mail or over the phone.
Subscribe

  • Farewell

    photognome died of heart failure yesterday. I don't have words right now.

  • My tweets

    Tue, 11:00: Pulling a full 250 KW and over 1,000 miles per hour charge rate at the new Reston teslamotors #SuperCharger. @ Wieh……

  • My tweets

    Fri, 19:57: Mixed meat meatballs, sauteed vegetables, loaded mashed potatoes with da_valentine and friends @ Corolla, North Car……

Comments for this post were disabled by the author